Athlete of the Year
Every year we recognize one student-athlete who has demonstrated outstanding achievement in their chosen sport(s). Our Athlete of the Year award is selected from the nominations of our head Varsity coaches. Each coach is able to nominate a student-athlete for recognition.
Past Winners
| Year | Name | Sport(s) |
| 1969 | Mark McKinnon | Baseball |
| 1970 | Bernard Stenson | All-American Swimming |
| 1971 | Mark Viera | Basketball/Track |
| 1973 | James Herrin | Soccer/Baseball |
| 1974 | Richard Kimball | All-American Track |
| 1975 | Herbert North | Soccer/Football |
| 1976 | Armando Jimenez | Track |
| 1977 | Paul Burke | Cross Country/Track |
| 1978 | Kevin Flaherty | Football/Baseball |
| 1979 | Phil Figone | Soccer |
| 1980 | Chris Prietto | Track |
| 1981 | Chris Prietto Rob Lambert |
Track Football/Baseball |
| 1982 | Michael Gerard Mike Zocchi |
Basketball/Baseball Football/Track & Field |
| 1983 | Patrick Oswald | Football All-American/Wrestling/Baseball |
| 1984 | Jason Clark | Diving All-American |
| 1984-85 | Tom Joseph | Football/Wrestling |
| 1985 | Rob Hinckley Mark Panella |
Football/Track Football/Baseball |
| 1986 | Antonio Vernon Michael Vontoure |
Football/Baseball Basketball/Baseball/Track |
| 1987 | Michael A. Gibson | Football/Baseball |
| 1988 | Robert Forester | Football/Wrestling |
| 1989 | Lou Donati | Baseball/Football |
| 1990 | Matt Clizbe Chris McClaughry |
Football/Track/Baseball Basketball |
| 1991 | Kevin Walker | Football/Baseball |
| 1992 | Amani Toomer | Football/Basketball |
| 1993 | Patrick Walsh | Football/Baseball |
| 1994 | Adam Carter | Water Polo/Basketball |
| 1995 | Leon Callen | Football/Track |
| 1996 | Rashad Floyd | Football/Basketball/Track |
| 1997 | Tom Prindiville Greg Brown-Davis |
Cross Country/Track Football/Wrestling/Diving |
| 1998 | Mike Hurlbut | Water Polo/Soccer/Swimming/Volleyball |
| 1999 | Atari Callen | Football/Track |
| 2000 | D.J. Williams | Football/Track |
| 2001 | Chad Taylor | Water Polo/Soccer/Swimming |
| 2002 | Matt Gutierrez | Football/Basketball |
| 2003 | Maurice Drew | Football/Track |
| 2004 | Parker Hanks | Football/Baseball |
| 2005 | Stefan Frei | Soccer |
| 2006 | Lincoln Gunn | Basketball |
| 2007 | Andrew Milcovich | Water Polo/Swimming |
| 2008 | Travis Carrie | Football/Track |
| 2009 | Chase Wheeler | Track |
| 2010 | Kristian Ipsen | Diving |
| 2011 | Dylan Wynn | Football/Wrestling |
| 2012 | Michael Barton | Football/Track |
| 2013 | Andrew Buckley | Football/Baseball |
| 2014 | Blair Hurlock Marquis Morris |
Cross Country/Track Football/Track |
| 2015 | Nathan Cervantez | Wrestling |
| 2016 | Devin Asiasi Jonathan Harvey |
Football Football/Track |
| 2017 | Jonathan Hackett | Football/Wrestling/Rugby |
| 2018 | Peyton Omania | Wrestling |
| 2019 | Henry To'oto'o Kyle Parco |
Football Wrestling |
| 2020 & 2021 | No selections due to COVID | |
| 2022 | Zeke Berry | Football |
| 2023 | Chukwunonso Udeh | Track and Field |
| 2024 | Alec Blair | Basketball/Baseball |